ProfitWell vs FlyCode: When Legacy Meets Modern AI in Payment Recovery

The subscription economy has fundamentally changed how businesses generate revenue, but it has also introduced new challenges around payment failures and involuntary churn. Two companies that have approached this problem from different angles are ProfitWell by Paddle Retain and FlyCode. While both aim to help subscription businesses recover lost revenue, their origins, technology, and approaches tell a fascinating story of how the payment recovery landscape has evolved.

The ProfitWell Story: From Bootstrap Success to Acquisition from Paddle

In 2012, looking to build something of his own, Patrick Campbell founded ProfitWell, a suite of products to help SaaS companies grow by optimizing pricing, reducing churn, and getting accurate revenue reporting. For the next decade, he ran ProfitWell as a bootstrapped startup, slowly growing its reach until the deal - valued at over $200m in cash and equity saw Paddle acquire the company in 2022.

ProfitWell's Legacy Technology Challenge

Founded over a decade ago means the platform was built on technology architecture from a different era.

What ProfitWell by Paddle Retain Does Well:

• Cancellation Flow Optimization: Automated cancellation flows learn and offer personalized retention offers to keep users subscribed

• Active Churn Management: Strong capabilities in managing voluntary churn through intervention strategies

• Analytics: Gather cancellation insights to help you diagnose the root cause for customers leaving your platform

The Technology Gap:

The core issue facing ProfitWell today is that ProfitWell was founded in 2012 and still runs on dated technology. While effective for its original purpose, the platform's approach to payment recovery relies on what FlyCode uses custom machine-learning models for each merchant, continually learning from your data, while ProfitWell relies on a brute-force fixed-interval retry schedule describes as outdated methodologies.

Enter FlyCode: AI-Native Payment Recovery for the Modern Era

FlyCode represents a new generation of payment recovery technology, built from the ground up with artificial intelligence and machine learning at its core. FlyCode is purpose-built for the AI era, with an AI-native payment-recovery platform and per-merchant ML models.

The FlyCode Advantage: Modern AI-Driven Approach

Core Technology Differences:

1. Custom Machine Learning Models: Custom ML model per merchant, continuously learning from your data vs ProfitWell's Global model based on aggregate benchmarks

2. Advanced Payment Intelligence: The AI-first models from FlyCode improve the merchant authorization rate and reduce issuer declines. As a result of being compliant with the card networks (Visa & Mastercard), FlyCode achieves superior recoveries

3. Performance Results: FlyCode outperforms ProfitWell by Paddle Retain in recovering failed payments by 25 %–40 % on average

4. Stripe and Shopify apps for no integration: you can start working with FlyCode with no dev work.

Specific Technical Advantages:

• Stripe Integration: FlyCode fully replaces Stripe's native retry model with models. ProfitWell simply stacks extra retries on top of Stripe, which can degrade auth rates

• Revenue Impact: By analyzing failure reasons, adapting retries dynamically, expanding retry windows and leveraging alternate payment methods, FlyCode boosts ARR by an average of 8%

• Customer Communication: FlyCode coordinates emails with its retry plan: no immediate emails after soft declines (reducing voluntary churn), distinct schedules for hard declines, sends at each customer's local time and uses high-deliverability transactional templates—far beyond Stripe's one-or-two default messages

Head-to-Head Comparison: Where Each Solution Excels

Real-World Performance: The Numbers

The performance gap between these solutions becomes clear when examining actual customer results:

FlyCode Success Stories:

• "FlyCode has been handling our failed payments recovery for Shopify and Recharge for the past year, delivering a 21% boost in recovery rates and a 9% reduction in involuntary churn. The impact is massive—12X ROI."

• a 46% increase in payment recovery from Q3 2023 to Q2 2024, ensuring improved retention and a more predictable revenue stream. Payment failure rate reduced by 11%!

• We took our failed payment recovery rate from 51% to a staggering 66% in just a month!

The Strategic Question: Legacy or AI native?

The choice between ProfitWell by Paddle Retain and FlyCode ultimately comes down to your business priorities:

Choose ProfitWell by Paddle Retain if:

• You're already heavily invested in the Paddle ecosystem

• Your primary concern is active churn and cancellation flow optimization

• You need active churn data

Choose FlyCode if:

• Failed payment recovery and involuntary churn are your primary concerns

• You want cutting-edge AI technology that learns from your specific data

• Maximum payment recovery performance is critical to your business

• You prefer best-in-class specialized solutions over all-in-one platforms

The Bottom Line: Specialization vs. Integration

While ProfitWell by Paddle Retain is focusing on basic recovery and cancellation flows with one-size fits all, at FlyCode focusing on involuntary churn with payment recovery models. This fundamental difference in approach reflects the broader evolution of SaaS tools from general-purpose platforms to specialized, AI-powered solutions.

The verdict: For businesses serious about maximizing revenue recovery from failed payments, FlyCode's modern, AI-native approach delivers measurably superior results. However, companies looking for an integrated solution within the Paddle ecosystem might still find value in ProfitWell's broader feature set.

The subscription economy demands precision in payment recovery. As involuntary churn becomes an increasingly critical metric for sustainable growth, the question isn't whether to invest in payment recovery technology—it's whether to settle for legacy solutions or embrace the AI-powered future.

The subscription economy waits for no one. Every failed payment that goes unrecovered is revenue lost forever. Choose the technology that matches your ambition.

FAQ