Open benchmarks
Failed Payment Recovery Benchmarks
Open benchmarks and reports on failed payment recovery and involuntary churn, maintained by FlyCode. Each one publishes its method and uses the billing platform’s own retries as the baseline.
subscription companies in the 2026 report
in failed payments analysed
recovery products graded on 21 jobs
Benchmark report
v1.0, November 2026
How much more does a dedicated recovery model recover than the billing platform’s own retries? Before and after results by failure cause, platform and business model.
Read the report →
Recovery rate, same accounts
Billing platform’s own retries
52.0%
With FlyCode
62.1%
17.6%
median lift in recovery rate
$22.6M
more recovered in six months
407
companies in the sample
Open benchmark
Provisional v0.1, August 2026
Stripe Failed Payment Recovery Benchmark
Which recovery tool delivers the highest lift over Stripe Smart Retries? Vendors are scored on public evidence, with incremental lift weighted at 45%.
1
FlyCode
8.8
2
Butter Payments
6.5
3
Churnkey
5.6
Score out of 10. Top 3 of 5 scored vendors.
Read the benchmark →
Index
v1.0, November 2026
Payment Recovery Index
Which jobs can each payment recovery product actually do? Six products graded job by job, from retry timing to cancel flows, with every grade sourced.
1
FlyCode
87
2
Paddle
65
3
Churnkey
61
Index score out of 100. Top 3 of 6 products.
See the index →
How these benchmarks are built
01
Lift, not gross recovery
Recovery numbers are reported as lift over the billing platform’s own retries, not as a gross recovery rate, because the platform already recovers a large share of failed payments on its own.
02
Method on the page
FlyCode maintains every benchmark on this page and publishes the method on the page itself.
03
Read it as vendor research
We sell payment recovery, so read the numbers with that in mind and check the sources.


