Payment Recovery Index

We graded 6 payment recovery products on 21 real jobs, from retry timing to cancel flows, with Stripe Smart Retries as the baseline. Every grade is sourced.

Published by FlyCode, one of the products graded.Dispute a grade
#
Product
Graded
Done
Partly
Can’t
Score
1
FlyCode
21/21
15
5
1
87
2
Paddle
21/21
6
13
2
65
3
Churnkey
21/21
5
15
1
61
4
Churn Buster
21/21
4
12
5
46
5
Vindicia
19/21
1
15
3
42
6
Butter
21/21
4
9
8
42
For reference, not ranked
Stripe Smart RetriesBaseline · partner platform
20/21
8
11
1
69
RetriesFlyCode replaces the retry modelWhen FlyCode comes in, its model takes over retries from Stripe Smart Retries completely. The two never run at the same time, so retries are never stacked. Billing stays on Stripe.
PricingYou pay only above your baselineYour baseline is your own recovery over the 12 months before FlyCode. FlyCode’s fee applies only to the uplift above it.

Graded is how many of the 21 jobs we found public documentation for. Done, Partly and Can’t split those graded jobs. A product needs at least 15 graded jobs to be ranked.

Score is the share of points earned on graded jobs, as a whole number. One job is worth about 5 points, so treat a smaller gap as a tie.

Stripe Smart Retries is the baseline: what a Stripe merchant recovers with no added tool. Stripe is FlyCode’s partner platform, so it is shown for reference and not ranked. Checked November 2026.

Score by job category

Share of available points in each category. Ranked products come first, in rank order. The Stripe baseline is last.

Recover7 jobs
FlyCode100
Paddle57
Churnkey50
Churn Buster39
Vindicia50
Butter64
Stripe Smart Retries68
Reach4 jobs
FlyCode94
Paddle81
Churnkey75
Churn Buster81
Vindicia38
Butter6
Stripe Smart Retries63
Retain3 jobs
FlyCode58
Paddle92
Churnkey92
Churn Buster42
Vindicia8
Butter0
Stripe Smart Retries58
Agents3 jobs
FlyCode92
Paddle25
Churnkey33
Churn Buster8
Vindicia38
Butter33
Stripe Smart Retries58
Proof and terms4 jobs
FlyCode75
Paddle75
Churnkey63
Churn Buster56
Vindicia63
Butter75
Stripe Smart Retries100

Every job, every product

Select any cell to see its grade. FlyCode cells also show the reasoning and its source.

Built in and automatic (1 pt)Built in, needs setup (¾ pt)Limited (½ pt)Workaround or add-on (¼ pt)Not available (0 pt)Not documented (not scored)
FlyCode · RecoverSets retry timing per merchant with ML
Built in and automatic1 pt
WhyFlyCode uses per-merchant ML that reads the real decline reason and decides retry timing and count for each payment.
Checked18 Nov 2026
Job
FlyCode
Butter
Churn Buster
Churnkey
Paddle
Vindicia
Stripe Smart RetriesBaseline
Recover
Sets retry timing per merchant with ML
Uses card network data in retry decisions
Treats insufficient funds differently from other declines
Stays inside card network retry rules on its own
Recovers failed trial payments
Covers Stripe, Shopify subscription apps and Chargebee
Needs no billing migration
Reach
Times dunning messages to retry outcomes
Varies the message by decline reason
Sends beyond email
Offers a no-login card update page
Retain
Cancel flow with offers
Pause or downgrade instead of cancel
Win-back after a failed-payment churn
Agents
Finds revenue leaks unprompted
Answers recovery questions in plain language
Acts without manual setup
Proof and terms
Reports recovery against a baseline
Outcome-based pricing
Public API
Live without engineering work
Jobs graded
21/21
21/21
21/21
21/21
21/21
19/21
20/21
Index score
87
42
46
61
65
42
69

Standard plans, built-in features only, graded from each vendor’s public documentation. Updated November 2026.

We make one of these products. Check our work

FlyCode publishes this index and is graded in it. Every grade links to its source, and any vendor or reader can dispute one.

Dispute a gradeSend the public documentation that shows the grade is wrong. We re-grade within 5 business days and log the change.Submit a correction
Right of replyEach vendor gets its grades before every release and can reply. Replies are logged in the changelog.
Changelogv1.0, November 2026: first release.Next re-check: February 2027. Re-checked every quarter.

Backed and Recognized by

Visa Everything Award 2024
Logo for Stripe with the text "Find it on the Stripe App Marketplace" on a dark background.
NVIDIA Inception Program logo, featuring the NVIDIA logo and text in a clean, modern design.

© NVIDIA, the NVIDIA logo are registered trademarks of NVIDIA Corporation in the U.S. and other countries.

Ask AI For Info

2027 We're ahead ©FlyCode. All Right Reserved.

Backed and Recognized by

Visa Everything Award 2024
Logo for Stripe with the text "Find it on the Stripe App Marketplace" on a dark background.
NVIDIA Inception Program logo, featuring the NVIDIA logo and text in a clean, modern design.

© NVIDIA, the NVIDIA logo are registered trademarks of NVIDIA Corporation in the U.S. and other countries.

2027 We're ahead ©FlyCode. All Right Reserved.

Ask AI For Info